Bank Regulation: Gould Votes Against Amex Resolution Feedback
Comptroller Jonathan Gould explains his vote against a joint FDIC and Fed resolution plan letter to American Express and calls for narrower living-will rules.

A resolution plan, often called a living will, is a bank’s blueprint for how it could be wound down in an orderly way, and on September 29, 2026 Comptroller of the Currency Jonathan V. Gould issued a statement explaining his vote against a joint FDIC and Federal Reserve feedback letter on American Express’s plan.
Key takeaways
- Mr. Gould voted against the joint letter to American Express Company and reaffirmed his call for changes to Dodd-Frank Act section 165(d) resolution planning.
- He argues the letter tells a non-systemically important bank to address significant concerns without detailing them or the consequences.
- He urged the agencies to revise the joint resolution plan rule so planning does not apply below the statutory threshold of $250 billion in total consolidated assets.
- The FDIC and the Federal Reserve published feedback letters the same day for resolution plans submitted in October 2025.
What Mr. Gould said
The OCC released excerpts of his remarks, with the full statement linked. He described opacity and uncertainty as hallmarks of the process. His criticism has three parts: the agencies direct the firm to address significant concerns with its resolution strategy without describing them or explaining the potential consequences; they keep full discretion to take more severe action if the concerns are not addressed in the next plan; and the options that would likely best protect the company are, in his view, costly and inappropriate for the organization.
He said the feedback, though not labeled a “shortcoming” or “deficiency”, is evidence that the process remains as unclear and unfair as when it began in the early 2010s. He also said banks have been pushed too far to structure themselves to fail, and that they should instead be built to serve the lending needs of their communities.
The wider release
The Federal Reserve’s release on the same date said the FDIC and the Federal Reserve jointly reviewed the October 2025 plans of 15 banking organizations with more than $250 billion in assets and did not identify any shortcomings or deficiencies. It published feedback letters for American Express, Barclays PLC, BNP Paribas, Deutsche Bank AG and UBS Group AG, plus a template letter for Category II and III firms. The agencies also determined that a shortcoming found in BNP Paribas’s 2021 plan had been satisfactorily addressed.
No formal shortcoming was found for American Express. The disagreement is over whether feedback of this kind should be given at all.
Why it matters
Mr. Gould’s position is that the agencies are required by statute to collect and review the plan because of the company’s asset size but are not required to deliver feedback unrelated to financial stability concerns. His proposal for a rule revision is a policy argument and not an action. The statement refers to an earlier occasion on May 22, 2026, when he issued a statement explaining an abstention from an FDIC vote on resolution plan feedback.
Key terms
- Resolution plan (living will): a plan describing how a firm could be resolved in bankruptcy or otherwise without severe disruption.
- Section 165(d): the Dodd-Frank Act provision requiring large firms to submit such plans.
- Shortcoming: a formal finding that a plan has a weakness that could impede orderly resolution.
FAQ
Did the agencies find a deficiency at American Express?
According to the Federal Reserve’s release, no shortcomings or deficiencies were identified in the 15 plans reviewed.
What would the Comptroller change?
He would revise the joint rule so resolution planning does not apply to companies below $250 billion in total consolidated assets.
Prepared with AI assistance from the public documents listed above and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.