BanqoDigest
GuideExplainer

Bank stress tests explained: how the Fed tests large banks

What bank stress tests are, how the Federal Reserve builds scenarios, how results set stress capital buffers for large banks, and how to read the release.

Glass office towers in a financial district seen from below
Glass office towers in a financial district seen from below. Image: shankar s. from Dubai, united arab emirates via wikimedia (CC BY 2.0)

A bank stress test is an exercise that estimates how a bank’s finances would hold up under a severe but hypothetical economic downturn. Supervisors give the bank, or run on the bank’s behalf, a scenario in which unemployment rises, asset prices fall and financial markets seize up. They then project losses, revenue and capital over the following quarters. The question is whether the bank would still have enough capital to keep lending after absorbing the shock.

In the United States, the best-known program is run by the Federal Reserve for the largest banking organizations. The test is not a forecast. Nobody expects the scenario to happen, and the Fed does not predict a recession. It is a way to measure resilience, and since the financial crisis it has become one of the main tools of bank supervision for large institutions.

In brief

  • The Fed runs annual supervisory stress tests on large banks under the Dodd-Frank Act and its own regulations.
  • Scenarios include a baseline and a severely adverse path; the Fed publishes them in advance and publishes results afterward.
  • Results feed into each bank’s stress capital buffer, an add-on to its minimum capital requirements.
  • A pass or fail label is a popular shorthand, but the real consequence is the size of the buffer and any limits on distributions.
  • Companion exercises exist for company-run tests and for market shocks affecting trading and counterparty exposures.

Where stress tests came from

During the 2007-2009 financial crisis, regulators and the public found it hard to tell which large banks were solvent. In early 2009 the US Treasury and Federal Reserve ran a one-time Supervisory Capital Assessment Program on the largest bank holding companies, and the disclosure of results helped restore confidence. The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 then made stress testing a recurring requirement for larger institutions. The Fed built two related programs: the Dodd-Frank Act stress tests (DFAST) and the Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review (CCAR).

Over time, the Fed folded the capital-planning requirement into the test results by creating the stress capital buffer, so that the severely adverse scenario now directly sets each large bank’s buffer. The agency’s page for the Dodd-Frank Act stress tests lists the scenarios, results and capital-requirement announcements for each year.

Which banks are tested

The Fed’s regulations tailor stress-test obligations to size and complexity. The largest and most interconnected firms face the most demanding requirements, including being included in the Fed’s supervisory test every year. Other firms above a size threshold may be tested less frequently or may be subject to different requirements. Banks below the thresholds are generally not subject to the supervisory stress test, though supervisors may still ask them to assess how they would perform in adverse conditions as part of normal risk management.

The exact thresholds and categories are set in the Fed’s regulations, including its Regulation Y and its stress-testing rules, and have been adjusted over time. Readers should consult the current rule text on eCFR and the Fed’s website rather than rely on a summary. The FDIC and OCC have separate stress-testing requirements for their own supervised institutions above certain asset sizes, which in practice operate differently from the Fed’s program.

How the supervisory test works

The test has several moving parts.

  1. Scenarios. Before the exercise, the Fed publishes the economic and financial paths it will use. According to the Fed’s 2025 stress test page, the Fed released that year’s scenarios in February 2025 and results in late June 2025. Paths typically include a supervisory baseline and a severely adverse scenario, plus additional market shock components that apply to firms with large trading operations. The page also lists data for historic and exploratory scenarios used in the Fed’s analysis.
  2. Data. Banks submit detailed information about their loans, securities, trading positions, revenue and capital to the Fed through regulatory reports.
  3. Models. The Fed uses its own models to project, for each bank, losses on loans and securities, trading and counterparty losses, pre-provision net revenue and balance-sheet changes over a multi-quarter horizon. The Fed publishes descriptions of its models and has also sought public comment on changes to them. Banks cannot see every parameter but can see the framework.
  4. Capital projection. Combining losses and revenue, the Fed projects each bank’s capital ratios through the end of the horizon, including the lowest point reached.
  5. Results. The Fed publishes aggregate and bank-level results, including the projected decline in capital under the severely adverse scenario.

The stress capital buffer

The stress capital buffer (SCB) is the bridge between test results and real requirements. It is a layer of capital that sits on top of each large bank’s minimum risk-based capital ratios, and its size reflects how far that bank’s capital ratio fell in the severely adverse scenario, plus planned shareholder distributions. A bank whose capital fell sharply in the test gets a larger buffer than one whose capital held up. The SCB replaced the fixed conservation buffer for these firms, so it varies bank by bank and updates as results change.

If a bank’s capital ratio falls into the buffer zone, it is not in default. It faces automatic limits on discretionary payments such as dividends, share repurchases and certain bonuses. The limits tighten the deeper into the buffer the bank falls. This design gives banks an incentive to hold more capital than the bare minimum and gives supervisors a graduated response.

Banks can ask the Fed to reconsider their requirement if they believe an error was made. The Fed’s page for the 2025 cycle notes that the Board announced final individual capital requirements for large banks effective October 1, and that it modified one firm’s requirement after that firm asked for reconsideration. The effective date and the reconsideration process are part of the annual cycle.

Company-run stress tests and the market shock

Alongside the supervisory test, larger banks have historically had to run their own stress tests and report the results. These company-run tests use the bank’s own models and scenarios, and they give supervisors a view into how management thinks about its risks. Requirements and frequency have changed over the years, so the current rule governs.

The global market shock applies a sudden repricing to trading assets and counterparty exposures, aimed at the banks with large trading books. Another component, the largest counterparty default, looks at the loss if a bank’s largest counterparty fails. These components are added to the main scenario for the firms they apply to.

How to read the annual release

When the Fed publishes results, newsrooms usually lead with whether banks “passed.” That is a simplification. A better approach is to read the release in this order:

  • Scenario severity. How deep is the projected recession, and how do unemployment, house prices, commercial real estate prices and equity prices move relative to the baseline?
  • Aggregate capital decline. The decline in the common equity tier 1 ratio, from starting point to the low point, for the group as a whole. The Fed’s 2025 page describes the results as showing that large banks are well positioned to weather a severe recession, which is the agency’s own characterization.
  • Bank-level dispersion. Which banks show the biggest capital declines, and why. Differences often reflect business mix, such as a large credit card book or a big trading operation.
  • Loss rates by portfolio. Credit card, commercial real estate, corporate loans and other categories.
  • Capital requirement announcements. Individual SCBs that take effect on a stated date, and the process for reconsideration.

A worked example

The numbers below are hypothetical and chosen to illustrate the mechanism; they do not describe any real bank.

A large bank starts the year with a common equity tier 1 (CET1) ratio of 13 percent. In the severely adverse scenario, the Fed projects that loan losses and trading losses exceed revenue, and the bank’s CET1 ratio falls to a low of 9 percent at its worst quarter. The decline is 4 percentage points. The bank also plans to pay dividends over the projection period, and the Fed includes that in the calculation.

The Fed then sets the bank’s SCB based on that decline and the planned payouts, subject to a regulatory floor. The bank’s total CET1 requirement is its regulatory minimum plus the SCB plus any surcharge that applies to globally systemic firms. If the bank holds more than that, it can pay out as planned. If it holds less, it must restrict distributions until it rebuilds capital. Management can respond by retaining earnings, cutting repurchases, raising capital, or shrinking risk-weighted assets.

Common misconceptions

“Failing a stress test means the bank is failing.” Not in the sense of insolvency. The stress test is hypothetical, and consequences are limits on payouts and a higher buffer.

“The results forecast what will happen.” They do not. The Fed states the scenario is not a forecast.

“Only the Fed runs stress tests.” Other agencies and banks run their own programs, and foreign supervisors, including the Bank of England and the European Banking Authority, run their own exercises.

“Stress tests protect depositors directly.” They support the safety and soundness of banks, which supports depositors indirectly. Deposit insurance is a separate protection, covered in our guide to FDIC deposit insurance.

FAQ

How often does the Fed run the stress tests?

The supervisory test for large banks is annual, with scenarios published ahead of results. The Fed’s 2025 page shows scenarios in February and results in June.

What is the difference between DFAST and CCAR?

DFAST is the stress test required by the Dodd-Frank Act. CCAR was a capital-planning review that used the same results. Today the stress capital buffer links the test directly to capital requirements, which reduced the separate role of the CCAR process.

What is a severely adverse scenario?

It is a hypothetical, deep recession with a sharp rise in unemployment, large drops in asset prices and stress in financial markets. The Fed publishes the variables and their paths before the test.

Do banks get to see the Fed’s models?

The Fed publishes model descriptions and, at various times, has invited public comment on its approach. Banks do not control the models, and the Fed does not disclose every parameter.

Where can I find the official results?

The Federal Reserve posts scenarios, results, methodology and capital requirement announcements on its stress test pages at federalreserve.gov. Regulation Y and related rules are on eCFR.

Prepared with AI assistance from the public documents listed above and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.